Is there a
Mormon political identity? I'm sure the first thought for many of us
is no. Every person has his/her own opinions, and religion should
not limit our political choices. When looking at aggregate
statistics, many of us will be surprised to find that there is indeed
a strong Mormon political identity. Although I do not think the
Mormon political identity constrains the political beliefs of members
of the LDS Church, I do recognize that the teachings of the LDS
Church influence its members political choices. So what causes this
Mormon political identity? Lets take a look at a few examples and
possible causes of the Mormon political identity.
First of all,
lets look at party affiliation in the LDS Church. In the United
States 65% of LDS Church members say they belong to or lean towards
the Republican party (Pond 2009). In contrast, only 35% of the
general US population say they belong to or lean towards the
Republican party (Pond 2009).
So why the
strong preference for the Republican party for Mormons? We can find
some explanation for this by looking at the primordialist and
constructivist arguments of political identity. As we discussed in
class, the primordialist argument says that identity is formed very
early in life (Hawkins 2012). Could factors from early life affect
the political identity of Mormons? I think to a certain extent the
primordialist argument could explain some of the Mormon political
identity. Many church members were born into the church—their
parents were members and often times even their parents and parents
parents were members. If you were raised in a conservative,
Republican household then I'm sure that would have some effect on
your personal political beliefs.
The
constructivist argument sheds further light on explaining the Mormon
political identity. According to constructivist theory, identities
are malleable (Hawkins 2012). Rather than developing our identities
while we are young, our identities are formed over time as a process.
So what factors would cause a Mormon political identity? First, the
teachings of the LDS Church greatly affect the political identity of
its members. For example, lets look at abortion. In the United
States, 27% of the general population think that abortion should be
illegal in most cases (Pond 2009). 61% of Mormons, however, think
that abortion should be illegal in most cases (Pond 2009). One
explanation for this is that the LDS Church does not support abortion
in most cases. Since most active members support the opinions of the
church, a Mormon political identity is formed. Mormons will
generally have similar political beliefs due to the influence of the
LDS Church's teachings on its members.
Although there
is definitely a Mormon political identity, that does not mean that
all members of the LDS Church have the same political beliefs or
opinions on all matters. There are many political factors that the
LDS Church does not have a stance on, and members can believe what
they want. Some controversial political topics like gay marriage
even build a political divide among Mormons. Although there is
definitely a general tendency for Mormons to be against gay marriage,
not all Mormons agree. The individual circumstances of each member
affects their opinions, like whether or not they have gay friends,
family, or acquaintances.
In summary, it
is evident that due to the LDS Church's teachings there is definitely
a Mormon political identity. According to the primordialist
argument, this is partly due to the fact that most Mormons are raised
in a Republican household. According to the constructivist argument,
the influences of the LDS Church's teachings influence the political
identity of Mormons. Due to other individual factors, not every
Mormon has the same beliefs though. The constructivist argument as
says that our political identity is malleable and it continually can
be changed. Despite the general tendency for Mormons to have similar
political beliefs, each one of use continues to form our own opinions
and beliefs according to our individual circumstances.
REFERENCES
Hawkins, Kirk.
BYU lecture on October 10, 2012. Political Science 150.
Pond, Allison.
2009. A portrait of Mormons in the U.S. The Pew Forum on Religion and
Public Life. http://www.pewforum.org/Christian/Mormon/A-Portrait-of-Mormons-in-the-US--Social-and- Political- Views.aspx
(accessed October 11, 2012).
No comments:
Post a Comment